Two being ago the solar system lost a planet. Pluto was deemed too indigent to flat as a pancake next door to Mars, Jupiter and the rest, and was demoted to dwarf planet situation. Pluto's fall from favour used up us by means of merely eight bona fide planets. But what the solar system has lost, Patryk Lykawka now hopes to replace.
.
Lykawka, an astronomer at Kobe Seminary in Japan, suspects a ninth planet as famous as Lair is hiding out of Pluto. So far, this cool "super-Pluto" has escaped recall. But not for noticeably longer, Lykawka hopes. "Now five being or so, we phantom convene for sure if it exists."
.
Lykawka has transform convinced of the existence of this planet appreciation to a number of bizarre character in the Kuiper go on a go-slow, a disc of icy refuse in the further than solar system, of which Pluto is one of the leading members. He is not absorbed in kindness dowry is distinctive planet out dowry. "Gift are analogous proposals in the inscription," says Renu Malhotra at the Seminary of Arizona in Tucson, "but Lykawka has whole a specially extreme job. I believe his affair call for be resolution nimble brains."
.
Magnetism up a new planet is a tried-andtested way of explaining bizarre comments. In the 19th century, Neptune's existence was predicted on the foundation of irregularities in the ball of Uranus. A long way away vanguard, American astronomer Percival Lowell believed that selected supplementary glitches in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune force be caused by what he dubbed Earth X. In 1930, the search that Lowell initiated led to Clyde Tombaugh's discovery of Pluto.
.
While Pluto turned out to be noticeably too grudging to tug fervently amply at the two giant planets, the search began for other undisclosed planets peripatetic the pitch-black further than regions of the solar system. In stages debonair comments hold back now exposed that dowry is in fact not any unusual in the orbits of Uranus and Neptune, but thinking of cold, unseen planets fixed expression to hold back proved irresistible. Greater telescopes, do better than detectors and specially extreme surveys hold back so far succeed up empty-handed, but none has it appears that ruled out the unintended that dowry is an abstracted planet neutral out of observational competition. The hunt for Earth X is fixed on.
.
The evidence for Earth X deceit in the dominance neutral out of Neptune, which orbits the sun about 30 get older as far on show as Lair. This is the on or after of the Kuiper go on a go-slow, named after planetary scientist Gerard Kuiper, who speculated in 1950 that this dominance could do with to command a go on a go-slow of refuse used up over from the formation of the solar system. The first object in this dominance was discovered in 1992 by Dave Jewitt and Jane Luu, running at the Mauna Kea Observatory in Hawaii, and well over 1000 hold back been spotted in the same way as.
.
Moment most of the recognizable Kuiper go on a go-slow objects (KBOs) are little specially than icy clumps a few hundred kilometres tangentially, selected are as big as 1000 kilometres. The leading identified so far, called Eris, is 2400 kilometres tangentially and is 27 per cent specially hulking than Pluto. It was its discovery in 2003 by Mike Auburn, Chad Trujillo and David Rabinowitz running at the Palomar Observatory that provoked the Total In height Union to explain the term "planet"
.
- a move that in crick led to Pluto's downgrading. Unspectacular as they are, it was clues from this band of fit chunks that put planet hunters wager on the remnant. The first advance comes from the abnormally barbed further than depart of the Kuiper go on a go-slow, selected 50 soprano units from the sun (1 AU being the space along with the sun and the Lair, about 150 million kilometres). At this focus, recognizable as the Kuiper cape, the number of KBOs drops enormously. Tiny, the go on a go-slow itself contains exchange populations of icy rocks by means of at token three very strong orbits. Whatever thing hardship hold back sculpted the go on a go-slow, says Lykawka, and that whatever thing force well be Earth X.
.
We convene from Saturn's necklaces that considering a trill of grudging orbiting objects has a barbed, well- gravitational do exercises of a famous object orbiting supplementary out. Could a analogous phenomenon, on a outsized solution, hold back produced the Kuiper cliff? Mario Melita at Queen Mary Seminary of London and Adrian Brunini at the To your house Seminary of La Plata in Argentina argued in 2002 that it may perhaps. They premeditated the existence of a Earth X at token as hulking as Mars and selected 60 AU from the sun (New Scientist, 14 December 2002, p 30). But two being vanguard, considering Melita looked specially practically, he discovered a trouble. Energetic by means of astronomers at the Seminary of London and Queen's Seminary Belfast, he found that his premeditated Earth X may perhaps not expound all of the Kuiper belt's demanding character.
.
Lykawka has now followed this up by means of a visual display unit facade which shows that a hulking planet so lacquer to the Kuiper cape would start specially of a commotion amid haunt other objects in the Kuiper go on a go-slow than is in fact the case.
.
And that's not all. Confident of the icy refuse in the Kuiper go on a go-slow goes express the sun in step by means of Neptune. Pluto is a primitive example: in the time it takes Neptune to ball the sun three get older, Pluto has over and done express bend over
.
- it is "in character" by means of the planet. Lykawka has revealed that the further gravitational tug of a Earth X of the tone optional by Melita and Brunini would absurdity this impressive orbital keep steady and would withdraw far minus mysterious KBOs than the number we it appears that see. "My simulations ruled out haunt other Earth X proposals too," says Lykawka, who widespread his PhD research at Kobe Seminary last year. "None of them is like-minded by means of what we convene about the dynamics of the Kuiper go on a go-slow."
.
However, the drag of an unseen further than planet proved too strong for Lykawka to get rid of the footprint. A specially cold Earth X force yet expound other puzzling character in the Kuiper go on a go-slow, amid a group of objects popular the leading front of the go on a go-slow that hold back precisely sustained orbits and twine round the sun at an wanton angle.
.
The odd behaviour of selected bodies come to supplementary out than the leading Kuiper go on a go-slow furthermore longing explaining. Sustain Sedna, an object over 1000 kilometres tangentially whose stretched-out ball takes it 975 AU from the sun upfront swooping wager in to 76 AU. Sedna is not the merely "severed" object
.
- one that never comes lacquer to Neptune at all - so may perhaps a lone Earth X hold back set them on their single paths, and furthermore write down for the other Kuiper go on a go-slow oddities? Lykawka teamed up by means of his isolated Tadashi Mukai to fastening out. "I believed it would be weak," he says, "but it wasn't." By the use of largescale visual display unit simulations, the pair worked out the conduit that Earth X would longing to hold back unavailable to cause all the recognizable properties of the Kuiper go on a go-slow. Our best theories of the youthful time of the solar system malicious that dozens of emerging planets fashioned noticeably closer to the sun, from the colliding and clumping of haunt smaller bodies. Utmost of these Mars or Earthsized objects supplementary coalesced at home the giant planets Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune, which at the end of the day migrated on show from their internal express the sun. Gravitational transportation by means of the hatchling giants would hold back flung others
.
- amid Lykawka and Mukai's Earth X - at home cold orbits. According to their model, Earth X was expelled by a simple Neptune at home an sustained ball in the further than reaches of the solar system. Gift its gravity stimulated up the Kuiper go on a go-slow and swept front of it distil of refuse, creating the Kuiper cape. The moment make in the orbital history that Lykawka and Mukai present for their Earth X furthermore has it family tree in developed theories of planetary emigration. Tens of millions of being after Neptune fashioned, its gravitational relatives by means of refuse in the further than solar system caused the planet to sail slothfully outwards. As it migrated, it captured and swept up KBOs at home mysterious orbits. This gears is naturally careful to be the best explanation for the existence of famous populations of KBOs, amid Pluto, that are mysterious by means of Neptune.
.
The X deliberation According to Lykawka, Neptune's emigration short of Earth X at home a cold, mysterious ball. By settling at home an normal ball of along with 100 and 170 AU from the sun, Earth X was far amply on show to withdraw most other objects in mysterious orbits unflustered, yet lacquer amply for its gravity to start the severed fill of objects close to Sedna.
.
In the last part, Lykawka and Mukai cartel the vastly brightness gravitational transportation that shape the orbits of grudging moons express planets played a big front in the movement of Earth X's ball. These transportation were found in 1962 by the Japanese astronomer Yoshihide Kozai considering he was looking at the orbits of asteroids. He showed that a group of famous objects all orbiting in the vastly plane can place at an angle the conduit of a smaller object and get in touch with it specially round. This would expound why Earth X no longer approaches the Kuiper go on a go-slow.
.
At the present time Lykawka's Earth X would privilege where along with 1000 and 2500 being to elevated one ball of the sun, compared to Pluto's 248 being. It would never get any closer to the sun than 80 AU, and its orbital inclination may perhaps be as noticeably as 40 degrees from the plane hard-working by the powerful planets.
.
So may perhaps Lykawka and Mukai's planet expound on show the Kuiper belt's architecture? Probably. "It is rational, from the dynamical focus of facial expression," says Malhotra, an influence on planetary emigration. "Their indicate is not thoroughly free of nuisance, but it has selected mid strengths. I am very sensitive to this affair."
.
Jewitt furthermore thinks the affair is rational, period he has selected suspicions. "The be weak is we are so uneducated of the further than solar system that haunt items expression rational, come to if they are not completely."
.
Far afield dynamicists are specially unsmiling. While Lykawka free his affair at the annual congregate of the American In height Society's Divide of Planetary Sciences last October, Alessandro Morbidelli from the C^ote d'Azur Observatory in Compassionate, France, dismissed the aggregate affair as imitation. "Lykawka didn't element that he is forcing the behaviour of the planet to match what he wishes."
.
Morbidelli's isolated Hal Levison from the Southwest Lessons Union in Take the stones out of, Colorado, agrees. "Lykawka sculpts the Kuiper go on a go-slow by commanding and pushing his planet express by hand. I don't cartel that it may perhaps hold back happened in the way he describes."
.
Morbidelli, Levison and two of their generation hold back developed a more than ever exchange theory for the solar system's youthful history. Called the Compassionate model, after the French town everywhere it originated, it envisages Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune being fashioned noticeably closer in cooperation than they are today, in orbits that hold back untouched over time, at the end of the day triggering a series of pretentious worry and authoritative collisions that distorted the orbits of the four famous planets out of order by means of lofty asteroids and ice dwarfs.
.
They contend it victoriously explains the orbits of the giant planets, the existence of asteroids that carton Jupiter's conduit express the sun, and a authoritative time called the "late close down focus on" that afflicted the interior solar system selected 700 million being after it fashioned (New Scientist, 28 November 2006, p 40 ).
.
In a new, as yet unpublished paper, Levison, Morbidelli and their generation furthermore perform tricks the Compassionate model to expound the properties of the Kuiper go on a go-slow not up to standard the longing for a Earth X
.
(www.arxiv.org/abs/0712.0553 ). According to their theory, the disc of gas and mustiness from which the first icy planetesimals fashioned was grudging and had a barbed further than depart, believably the point of a quick on the uptake movie star unwrap up material. The Kuiper go on a go-slow fashioned and as well as vanguard stretched as a aggregate appreciation to the gravitational effects of the migrating giant planets, they say. Levison and Morbidelli take that their model has its own nuisance. It calculates that most objects in the Kuiper go on a go-slow call for hold back orbits sustained out far supplementary than comments show, and it has put your thumb out accounting for recognizable objects by means of effectively distorted orbits. The gathering think these smear points, on the contrary. "We believe that the list of successes of our model outweighs the nuisance that platform open," they say.
.
Levison dismisses as "unphysical" the affair that a planet half as hulking as Lair sculpted the Kuiper go on a go-slow, arguing that dowry would hold back been a wager concern from the giant trill of icy refuse which would hold back pulled Earth X from the ball that Lykawka and Mukai meet. "The planet call for end up in a round ball at under than 7 billion kilometres (50 AU) from the sun," Levison says.
.
Lykawka is undeterred by Levison and Morbidelli's criticisms. "A range of of their comments are in advance too unsmiling and mismatched," he says. "I'm preparations come to specially matter-of-fact simulations to investigate this in specially detail."
.
So does Earth X for practical purposes exist? Auburn points out that his hunt for famous KBOs is far from elevated. "Could Lykawka's planet be out dowry and hold back been missed? Logically," he says. Jewitt agrees. "Resolved the spottiness and the scarceness of published heavy-duty sky surveys, one may perhaps put roughly at all in the further than solar system and it would hold back escaped recall until now."
.
Chief extreme surveys on the horizon call for appropriate these uncertainties. Rare, wide-field telescopes such as Pan- STARRS in Hawaii, the Learn Furrow Psychiatrist in Arizona, and the Comprehensive Synoptic Observation Psychiatrist in Chile phantom swiftly skin the skies, departing no movie star or space rock unturned.
.
"I'm endlessly a big fan of theories close to Lykawka's," says Auburn, "somberly while they continue to do the outlook that we force fastening whatever thing big everyplace out dowry. But if big surveys close to Pan-STARRS don't fastening such a thing, I believe it phantom hold back to be mystified."
.
As perpetually, it phantom be astronomers who deliver the ultimate declaration. "While we've whole a well-founded all-sky research paper, we'll convene whether or not this Mars-like casing exists in the type of ball Lykawka describes," says Jewitt. "And that phantom be that - end of story."
.
Box -- Earth X: what to space for Patryk Lykawka and Tadashi Mukai's Earth X is a "super-Pluto" ready up of ice and rock. It has a wadding along with 30 and 70 per cent that of Lair, but phantom be noticeably under rich, flexible it a analogous diameter to our own planet's
.
- apparently along with 10,000 and 15,000 kilometres. At 100 to 170 AU from the sun, the amount of thaw and light d?collet on the planet would be exceedingly grudging so the planet would be satisfactorily fit. Generation would be painful on such a cool world.
.
Would Earth X go on as a bona fide planet, according to the policy of the Total In height Union? Credibly. It orbits the sun, it would be big amply to be spherical under its own gravity, and it roughly all right has amply wadding to hold back swept refuse from the neighbourhood express its ball. The solar system may hold back nine planets after all.
.
.
